Statement Regarding Ethics Board Ruling on Baxter’s Business

Last week, we learned that Sheriff Todd Baxter was among the Monroe County officials who knew about a 2025 state report into the painful and preventable death of a man in the Monroe County Jail and failed to disclose it to the County Legislature. At the same time, Baxter was making money through a private consulting business that sold other sheriffs a program called “Transforming Jail Culture.”

Today, we learned that activity has to stop.

The Monroe County Board of Ethics concluded that Baxter & Barnes Leadership’s law-enforcement programs “appear closely related” to Baxter’s responsibilities as Sheriff and “appear to be part of his job duties.” The Board recommended that Baxter “forthwith cease” his development of, participation in and association with those programs while he remains Sheriff.

Baxter agreed.

That is a significant outcome, and it is exactly why I filed this complaint. The Sheriff should not operate a private business selling services that overlap with the job Monroe County taxpayers already pay him to perform.

Some news coverage today described the report as finding no conflict of interest, and as concluding that BBL is not related to his responsibilities. That is not what the report says. The Board reached two different conclusions about two different categories of BBL’s programs. It found the general leadership training unrelated to his job and no violation there. But for the law-enforcement-specific programs, it found the opposite. Those programs “appear closely related” to his duties as Sheriff, and the Board recommended he stop offering them entirely. He agreed to comply.

But I strongly disagree with the Board’s refusal to find an Ethics Code violation.

In 2023, the same Ethics Board found Baxter violated Section 45-13.A merely by appearing in an unpaid television commercial for a collision shop. He wasn’t wearing his uniform, his title wasn’t displayed, and he wasn’t paid. The Board found he acted in good faith and without intent to violate the Ethics Code, and explicitly held that intent was not required to find a violation.

Now Baxter owns a for-profit company selling law-enforcement services the Board itself says appear to be part of his official duties. The Board identified potential conflicts involving BBL customers who could seek jobs, promotions or contracts from the Sheriff’s Office or even become subjects of investigations. It recommended changes to how Baxter uses his uniform and public office to promote the company. And it told him to stop doing the law-enforcement work entirely.

Yet somehow, this time, there is no violation.

That makes no sense.

I am also deeply troubled by how this report became public. The Board transmitted it to County Executive Adam Bello. Sheriff Baxter was then able to release the report himself and characterize its findings before I had even been given a copy. The subject of an ethics complaint should not get the opportunity to control the public release and set the narrative while the person who brought the complaint is denied the report.

My complaint accomplished something important. Sheriff Baxter will stop using his private business to sell law-enforcement programs while serving as Monroe County Sheriff.

But the public deserves consistent application of our Ethics Code and a process that does not give the official under investigation an advantage in telling the public what the Ethics Board actually found.

Finally, the Ethics Board is functionally controlled by the County Executive, because the legislature does not have any appointments. I will work on a resolution reforming the board’s structure.